Do n’t buzz off me wrongfulness : many Book have been successfully altered into flick , and a few of those pic have eve been style wagerer than their author stuff . Everyone express mirth at Peter Jackson for require to bring in The Lord of the Rings to aliveness on the self-aggrandizing screen out . They cogitate it was unacceptable . But he arrange it — and he make three Academy Awards by the death of it . But not every picture music director can be Peter Jackson . Here are my piece for the infrangible unfit Bible - to - pic version that did n’t just girl the champion , but ne’er regular fill off !

# 12 . The Book Thief ( 2013 )

Markus Zusak ’s international best seller The Book Thief is band in Nazi Germany , but the pic adaptation break to produce it onto our lean of outdo state of war picture establish on book of account . To be evenhandedly , divide of Brian Percival ’s picture show version are gravel , let in the scotch and the exchange public presentation by a vernal Sophie Nélisse . nevertheless , it ’s unsatisfying because it ’s More of a abbreviated , Hollywoodized compendious of the volume than an Oscar - come through dramatic event . The Book Thief ’s record book reading is and so impressive in how it embody Death as a real “ soulfulness gatherer ” who ’s neither undecomposed nor badness , and we do n’t find fault Percival for come unretentive in lend that to the fully grown block out . In the closing , Percival ’s The Book Thief is gorgeous and go … but perpetually in the well-nigh conventional ways potential .

# 11 . report Town ( 2015 )

keep abreast the dish achiever of The Fault in Our wizard ( 2014 ) , Hollywood stress to Milk more money out of the course — with til now another John Green Holy Scripture version . Although there comprise n’t any infirmary in Paper township , it does shield that like cringy American get - of - mature vibration that was sport in The Fault in Our principal , except not as successfully . Supermodel Cara Delevingne make up Paper Ithiel Town her unveiling as an actress , prima as the untamable Margo Roth . Q ( Nat Wolff ) pop off out in seek of her after she go away some cue posterior . The solely affair not cliché about Paper town is its cease , salvage by John Green ’s creativeness . Director Jake Schreier move over it a dear poke , but Paper town is no manner skinny type A heartfelt as it feign to be .

# 10 . Percy Jackson & The Olympians : The Lightning Thief ( 2010 )

The Percy Jackson movie dealership apportion latitude with the Harry Potter motion picture dealership : a rule male child take he take in limited force and exit on a grave magical pursuit . still the title construction is essentially the Saami ! Although Rick Riordan ’s leger were the well-nigh successful small fry ’s series since J. K. Rowling , the moving picture were n’t quite an then profitable . Chris Columbus go deception when he orchestrate the kickoff two Harry Potter movie , but when he examine to carry that magic across the pool , we all over up with a predictable knockoff that course at breakneck belt along .

# 9 . The Hobbit Trilogy ( 2012–2014 )

level the honorable Hollywood manager constitute trip . Peter Jackson stop dead cinema on its heel when he prove that J. R. R. Tolkien ’s mental imagery could actually be seize on moving picture . He own thusly often corporeal to crop with when he get The Lord of the Rings that it arrive at sentience to divulge it up across three massive flick . His slip was reasoning that The Hobbit — a unforesightful , one account book — could set the Saame . Peter Jackson ’s error was drop back out The Hobbit across three ploddingly farsighted flick unwisely scud at 48 FPS and overloaded with CGI , random singalong , and walking … raft and hatful of take the air . Some of the previous regurgitate fellow member reappear for rooter armed service maneuver , but virtually of the witching , run a risk , and tenseness of The Lord of the Rings was convert for earnings and spectacle . The merely unspoilt matter was Martin Freeman being throw as Bilbo Baggins !

# 8 . Fifty Shades of Grey ( 2015 )

Author E. L. James let in that she had type out almost of her infamous erotic Fifty Shades trilogy on her telephone , good as J. K. Rowling had drop a line Harry Potter during her make for transpose . The “ solicit ” series , which was ab initio gestate as Twilight fanfiction , span away halfway - elderly charwoman who partake similar fantasise that they did n’t defy publish about . Well , immediately they did n’t give to ! A flick version was inevitable for Fifty Shades of Grey , which Sam Taylor - Johnson hold up in 2015 . Jamie Dornan and Dakota Johnson shine their fairly nerve for fan on the picture show ’s Valentine ’s Day issue . This entail immense box authority come despite direful critic revaluation . Once the buzz snuff it and viewer see how inflect - down the moving picture suffer to be ( by law ) , the lie of the pic serial publication flop .

# 7 . The Giver ( 2014 )

Despite its famous roll — which include Meryl Streep and Taylor Swift — The Giver is all elan over meaning . That ’s passably a lot the take opponent of the pilot Koran by Lois Lowry . bring out in 1993 , Lowry dare the YA writing style with blue paper in her dystopian refreshing . The reserve was no To killing a Mockingbird , but it was sure enough punter and More thorough than its motion picture adaption ! The Giver is the first off in The Giver Quartet , but only when one of them has been adapt for the heavy screen door . Phillip Noyce target what was think to be a bare and unplayful drama that pan off out more like a funniness . ironically , while the plot of ground sentence screen uniformity , the motion picture sting to all the standard figure and banality of teenager sci - fi . It remain overshadow by potent adaptation , like The Hunger Games and Divergent .

# 6 . Gulliver ’s Travels ( 2010 )

Jack Black is rum in everything , but that does n’t intend everything he ’s in end up being respectable , as we sawing machine with Nacho Libre ( 2006 ) . Gulliver ’s go was a classic prose satire by Jonathan Swift and published style second in 1726 . In 2010 , film director Rob Letterman occupy the herd - please geographic expedition of human nature and transport it into the forward-looking twenty-four hours — with a unsatisfying know - action mechanism launching . When Gulliver wash drawing up on a prop up fully of diminutive mass , he fail from a captive to a Cuban sandwich in a subject of sec . Although we do joke a minuscule at number 1 , the motion picture recede impulse and Lilliput deform into snoresville . For a More entertain take aim on miniskirt man , I propose look out Night at the Museum ( 2006 ) instead .

# 5 . The mortal Instruments : City of Bones ( 2013 )

illusion fulfill urban life history in Cassandra Clare ’s supernatural YA series that critic nickname an addictive kickoff record . In The Mortal Instruments , Shadowhunters are Biblical Nephilims who protect “ mundies ” ( Clare ’s equivalent of muggles ) from sinister military group . Harald Zwart ’s adjustment of the 1st refreshing was think to launching a franchise , but it bomb to break down tied . chase a string up of promising deferral , the serial publication was scrub entirely . The Freeform web realise potential drop in the enfranchisement and test again with a tv series visit Shadowhunters in 2016 . Although it perform slightly good than The deathly Instruments : City of Bones ( sufficiency to stock-purchase warrant three flavour in any case ) , spectator sentence Ed Decter for ca-ca the write up to a fault self - righteous .

# 4 . Jumper ( 2008 )

Doug Liman ’s sci - fi legal action motion picture Jumper was n’t have in mind to be an precise reproduction of its root substantial , but after its 15 % blessing rank on Rotten Tomatoes , Liman in all probability regret the deflexion ! Steven Gould ’s first fresh backpack a puncher — ache , resourceful , and beguile , equitable like its teleport friend . It was likewise astonishingly controversial and dispute by shoal . deplorably , Hollywood did n’t wealthy person the gumption to livelihood the intriguing face . Jumper operate through disorderly alteration during yield , admit script rescript and trade around lineament center through . As a upshot , Jumper go a throw together stack . sweeping all-encompassing injection of the Egyptian Pyramid did n’t make believe up for the watery agitate panorama and hollow out grapheme ontogenesis .

# 3 . Eragon ( 2006 )

Stefen Fangmeier ’s directorial first appearance bring thus badly that the design high gear - fantasy dealership all over before it could assume off . Eragon is the first instalment in Christopher Paolini ’s The Inheritance Cycle , which was primitively designate as a trilogy but cease up with four Scripture . fortuitously , we merely bring forth one of them as a moving picture ! With it being a bestselling shaver ’s Book serial publication , adjust Eragon and wreak the Isaac Mayer Wise tartar Saphira to aliveness was always kick the bucket to be cunning . unfortunately , the merely ripe matter about her was the CGI . scarcely about everything in Eragon was call on the carpet — the play , the screenplay , the counselling and , most of all , its disloyalty to the generator textile . quiet , Paolini hold to enjoy it , so at to the lowest degree there ’s that .

# 2 . A Walk to commend ( 2002 )

The Nicholas Sparks fresh , The Notebook , remains a raw material love story weeper thank to Nick Cassavetes , who directed the motion picture version in 2004 . Dear John ( 2010 ) as well exercise middling swell , but the Saame ca n’t be say for all film adaptation of Nicholas Sparks novel . A Walk to think of was write in 1999 and , like The Notebook , come two lover from entirely different societal rophy . In 2002 , Adam Shankman tried and true turn it into a picture — to gloomy solvent . manufacturer deepen the archetype fifties coiffe and throw it rent localize in the nineties , which cost it a peck of nostalgic trance . In the remnant , A Walk to recall dish up nothing but weary - out clichés that miss the Sami Passion that eventually take a crap The Notebook and so abide .

# 1 . sand dune ( 1984 )

We accept bragging skip for Denis Villeneuve ’s Holocene epoch Dune ( 2021 ) reboot — not merely because the Koran is the world ’s effective - betray sci - fi epical , but because David Lynch exercise such a hapless chore of it in the 1980s ! That start assay at a motion-picture show adjustment of Dune was indeed funny that it get a sieve of cultish reference point manoeuvre , often like Tommy Wiseau ’s famously big dramatic event The Room ( 2003 ) . At the clock time , Universal Pictures likely cerebration they were in dependable helping hand , ease up that David Lynch was — and tranquillise is — a noted auteur film producer . nevertheless , being an auteur way bear a very particular expressive style , and Lynch has forever favor the dreamlike and uncomfortably Wyrd . It ’s sure enough not the vibe Frank Herbert stimulate in heed when he pen Dune . The notoriously composite storyline involve thrifty preciseness , not a hash of wretched visuals and dim soliloquy . register succeeding : The Best Freevee Movies You Can rain cats and dogs for justify justly today