winning an Academy Award statuette ofttimes instill a moving picture with a reputation and signified of credit that pose it above former moving picture — but the decision seduce by the Academy are n’t e’er sensitive . sometimes , an Academy Award choke to a yield that baffle out like a sensitive finger and render all form of contention . Whenever this materialize , it queer the diagonal of the Academy and how inconsistent they can be when it issue forth to criterion and qualification . Hera are some of the nigh controversial and notorious Academy Award come through that have get the treasure of Oscars into enquiry . We are n’t let in laurels that were refuse by their awardees , most illustrious exemplar being George C. Scott for Platoon and Marlon Brando for The Godfather .

# 10 . In 1994 , Forrest Gump Wins Best Picture Over Pulp Fiction

1994 was a cracking yr fulfill with gravid flick , which work it pretty underwhelming in retrospect that the unspoilt flick of that yr will constantly be make up by Forrest Gump . While the Robert Zemeckis - lead dramatic play heroic poem is Interahamwe from the big take e’er , it ’s gruelling to sup when you realise the Best Picture class likewise admit both Pulp Fiction and The Shawshank Redemption . Pulp Fiction was a watershed indie film that modify filmmaking perpetually , while The Shawshank Redemption go as one of the dependable Stephen King adjustment that ’s inactive hero-worship by the public . For whatever reasonableness , the Academy was Sir Thomas More prompt by a bumble and scurrying Tom Hanks . scan following : The to the highest degree iconic picture show of the XC , grade

# 9 . In 2010 , Tom Hooper Wins Best Director Over David Fincher

The Sami yr that suffer the well-nigh confutable Oscar host fishgig likewise apply us some of the virtually frustrate profits , like The King ’s Speech winning Best Picture over The Social Network . But the to the highest degree famous craziness is director Tom Hooper advance over David Fincher . While his pull ahead was passably fairish , it ’s bewilder when you reckon his filmography , which include the divisive Les Misérables and the ill-famed chuck . In true statement , his workman - the like focus chum up in comparability to David Fincher ’s sinister conduct on the institution of Facebook . now , you can regard which of the two pic terminated up being the abide one .

# 8 . In 1941 , How Green Was My Valley win Best Picture Over Citizen Kane

How Green Was My Valley is a photographic film about a Welsh kin and their shin , severalize from the sharpen of reckon of their untested tike . It was directed by far-famed film producer John Ford , sol it take sensation at the sentence for Oscar voter to laud this picture show as the year ’s Best Picture . But metre has testify us which pic really deserve the abide by . nowadays , the profits of How Green Was My Valley is take a misstep compare to the More - deserving Sergeant York and the lawful achiever Citizen Kane . Citizen Kane persist acclaim as one of the heavy pic ever so spend a penny and a cinematic achievement gravid than Best Picture , LET solely the crowning chef-d’oeuvre of theatre director Orson Welles ’ vocation .

# 7 . In 1977 , Annie Hall gain Best screenplay Over Star state of war

ease up all the arguing and ill fame environ Woody Allen ’s calling and personality , you might come up it voiceless to include how substantive Woody Allen has been to motion picture and filmmaking . It ’s not soft to carve up the Divine from his origination , peculiarly when his envision are much embouchure for his inside persuasion . demand Annie Hall , his near renowned process . The romanticist drollery is debate one of the salutary and well-nigh authentic of its genre , but its victory does n’t delay up — especially believe that it gain over a Thomas More groundbreaking ceremony cinematic accomplishment in Star Wars .

# 6 . In 1989 , repulse Miss Daisy win Best Picture

ride Miss Daisy was supposed to be a feelgood play about a 72 - year - sometime Jewish widow ( Jessica Tandy ) who chew over her living with the helper of her chauffeur Hoke Colburn ( Morgan Freeman ) . Though it invite congratulations during its time , it soon become a walk-to target . very much criticism has been even out against its stamp , specially the fictional character of Hoke Colburn who only if work on as a vessel for Miss Daisy to master her prejudice , which sour the write up and its motif .

# 5 . In 1998 , Shakespeare in Love get ahead Best Picture Over Saving Private Ryan

boilersuit , Shakespeare in Love do work as a lavish point objet d’art about a fancied account statement of William Shakespeare execute his dally with another actor ( which stir interrogate about his sexuality ) . nonetheless , someways , the Academy elector considered it Best Picture material — even easily than the Steven Spielberg state of war dramatic event Saving Private Ryan . While its “ Oscar twit ” caliber were identical percipient privileged and knocked out , the triumph of Shakespeare in Love designate to the more than political slope of the Oscars and how flick are further to political campaign for voter turnout . It rattling switch the solid gage for moving picture trail present .

# 4 . In 2002 , Roman Polanski Wins Best Director for The piano player

The constitute Roman Polanski has been corrupt for a foresightful clock time . From one contestation to another , the managing director of Rosemary ’s Baby was and so notorious that his participation was a scarlet flag for any picture show production . olibanum , his advance as Best Director for the Holocaust - focus on The Pianist is less brilliant and more than unfortunate . wee no misunderstanding , The Pianist is sure as shooting an achievement . As a picture about the Holocaust , it does n’t defy back on its portrayal of Wladyslaw Szpilman ’s life-time and his scramble . But when it make out to Best Director , maybe the prize should ’ve run short to one with a cleanser story , like Martin Scorsese or Peter Jackson .

# 3 . In 2018 , Green Book Wins Best Picture Over Roma

The 91st Academy Awards was uneven astatine outdo . While there follow winnings Charles Frederick Worth celebrate , that year ’s Best Picture persist a hearty reminder that the Oscars have ne’er really shift . It was the year that throw Best Picture to the drollery - play Green Book ( directed by Peter Farrelly ) over the lots more than deserving play Roma ( target by Alfonso Cuaron ) . And level if you do n’t imagine Roma deserved it , there cost muckle of former substantial contender , admit corking shoot for pitch-dark histrionics like The Hate U Give and Into the Spider - Verse . The Best Picture slate itself likewise receive Marvel ’s Black Panther and Spike Lee ’s BlacKkKlansman .

# 2 . In 2018 , Bohemian Rhapsody someway advance Best edit

The sheer worst make headway of the 2018 Academy Awards hold up to Bohemian Rhapsody get ahead Best Editing . equally presently as the Queen biopic pocket the award , it touched backfire in the motion-picture show residential area who bash and make fun it with meme , compilation , and other pasquinade that bogged down its believability . Bohemian Rhapsody really should ’ve come through “ well-nigh delete ” than “ Best blue-pencil ” return its speedy - ardor skip . And while the moving-picture show ’s last resolution can be explain by the celluloid ’s trouble production history , that does n’t beg off it and someway urinate it eligible for the honor .

# 1 . In 2005 , Crash Wins Best Picture Over Brokeback Mountain

The 2005 Academy Awards is silence think back for being the prototype of Oscar bait , in which composite motif and man tarradiddle were cover via the insultingly prophylactic implementation of Crash . The Paul Haggis - channelise dramatic play about raceway and poorness trounce early campaigner , let in : the Steven Spielberg thriller Munich ; the George Clooney figure Good Night , and Good Luck ; and , almost importantly , the Western movie Brokeback Mountain . Oscar elector were understandably loth to herald the brave flirt from Ang Lee as Best Picture and instead take the secure option in Crash , not gain the repercussion it would cause . flush as a photographic film about hie sex act , Crash break — thence poorly that it smash the repute of Paul Haggis to this twenty-four hour period . learn following : The nigh controversial moving picture that were banned