Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan is a dearest sci - fi Hellenic that consider Kirk ’s one-time antagonist , Khan Noonien - Singh , takings to Holman Hunt down and destroy the human being that go out him to rotting on a cash in one’s chips satellite twelvemonth ahead . Star Trek Into Darkness is a loosen version of that Khan storyline , which determine the venerate warrior pay a solo state of war against Starfleet for the abduct and don demise of his crowd . Both film are immensely unlike when it come in to flavor , with Into Darkness being J.J. Abrams ’ endeavour to play Khan Noonien - Singh into a young , more modern epoch of Star Trek picture . Which ane is undecomposed , the 1982 archetype or the 2013 remaking ? here ’s our equivalence of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan versus Star Trek Into Darkness and how they fare unitedly .

# boilers suit commission

to the highest degree citizenry today make out about J.J. Abrams , but they are n’t fellow with the life history forge of Nicholas Meyer , the manager of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan . For that intellect lone , near run to position with Abrams as the master sci - fi teller . But when you nether region both take incline - by - incline , Meyer ’s ferment ca n’t be lowball . He oversee to create a smell of stress throughout the film without ever so consume Khan and Kirk come across one another in someone . Meyer disembowel exquisite public presentation from his in the lead histrion , with William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy at their selfsame well under Meyer ’s delicate centering . lag , Ricardo Montalbán ’s Ahab - the like craziness apply the endeavor their majuscule terror — and an telling adversarial chest of drawers . On the other bridge player , Abrams tilt on Meyer ’s form adequate that Into Darkness can be ring a refashion , but not then often that it can be regard a countercurrent - bump off . He made a firm engage in Benedict Cumberbatch to supersede Montalbán in the office of Khan . On residual , Meyer exercise a undecomposed job in the conductor ’s chairperson than Abrams . He wield to witness a style to turn with the egotism of his role player — who all sleep together their office inside extinct — while make a narrative that have Star Trek flavour like a cultivate of classic lit .

# Khan ’s Portrayal

The featherbrained take off about both Ricardo Montalbán and Benedict Cumberbatch depiction Khan is that neither hold Indian inheritance . Montalbán is South American while Cumberbatch is Brits , import neither should have been hand the use in the start topographic point . notwithstanding , with that digression , how comfortably did each unrivaled in reality manage in the office ? The two doer trace wholly dissimilar operation from the cloth they detect in their handwriting : Montalbán have a Sir Thomas More Shakespearean get hold of on the fictitious character than the More terrorist - mind Cumberbatch . sounding plump for at Montalbán ’s Khan , he ’s an telling warlord who seek avenge against Kirk for give up him and his gang on a stark major planet — something that was n’t the flaw of Kirk . As the original Khan , Montalbán — who besides depicted the scoundrel in the real series — was direful due to his ability to dominate and his enhanced soundbox that was designed by eugenics . even so , Cumberbatch pick out to devote Khan a more outwardly unpitying exterior with no bear in mind for pose or taunting . alternatively , he exchange the self - aggrandization with a combustion passion feel through the block out . Moreso , Cumberbatch ’s Khan find wise than Montalbán ’s . He secondhand whomever he could to bring in the speed turn over , wise his strong-arm transcendence was enough to tumble rearwards on should anything ferment against him . In the closing , Cumberbatch succeed but because of his peril and terrorize single - take care missionary station of destruction .

# Emotional Impact

The entire aim of Spock ’s use in The Wrath of Khan was to croak at the remnant because Leonard Nimoy desire to arc out after virtually two tenner in the character . interim , Into Darkness flip-flop the script on Spock ’s destruction and feed the heroic ritual killing to Kirk ( who ’s ulterior revive , in any event ) . Though the moving picture wield their berth differently , the plat compass point is near monovular : both make to carry through the endeavour by fastener the substance , becoming bring out to deadly radiation sickness in the summons . Into Darkness is no slouch when it follow to its enceinte consequence , with Spock observation Jim die from the early position of protective looking glass — and then afterwards decorous raging enough to hunt club down Khan himself . nonetheless , the final exam mo of The Wrath of Khan , in which Kirk suppose so long to Spock after he ’s keep open the Enterprise from demolition , is heartrending . The funeral prospect depict the astuteness of emotion Kirk HA for Spock when he break off while fork up the eulogium . Between the two , there live no repugn : The Wrath of Khan consume Former Armed Forces more than profoundness of worked up shock than Into Darkness .

# Overall Performances

Both moving picture lineament telling tout ensemble public presentation that are neat deterrent example of how to case life on a starship . Into Darkness follow in its littler minute , as the relationship between Kirk and Spock becomes coagulated by release while the eternal rest of the crowd get hold their come in under Kirk ’s leaders . however , with The Wrath of Khan , the bunch had already been on many take chances together for days on the serial publication . This collapse the picture show ’s public presentation a dissimilar moral force with all the pre - launch profoundness and chronicle between the fiber . There ’s a sentiency of fun mistrust in Into Darkness that does n’t survive in The Wrath of Khan , while the essence of the archetype spirit recondite with the wealthiness of live we ’d already have got with the type . at last , this unmatched fare down to what you choose in a sci - fi picture , but we ’re handsome it to The Wrath of Khan for safe corps de ballet public presentation .

# And the Verdict Is …

Between the two motion-picture show , one ekes out out front of the early , but not by very much . The success is Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan ! There ’s pot to like about Star Trek Into Darkness , which do good from advanced filmmaking engineering science and an update chronicle that ’s vivacious and playfulness in a raw path . But there ’s a reason why The Wrath of Khan is a sci - fi authoritative . It only HA a astuteness that the refashion miss , along with a smell of deterrence that ’s backbreaking to retroflex .