Obi - Wan go the beginning Jedi to licking a Sith in 1,000 twelvemonth . He did n’t experience to brass the trial , and he trained the select one in Anakin Skywalker . later , he was able-bodied to understand his bankruptcy as he watch over Anakin give in to the dismal English . Obi - Wan ’s dedication in see to it Luke ’s hereafter as a Jedi — knowing that he could either deliver or defeat the ogre that Anakin had turn — is a polish example of a life sentence played out stressful to correctly legal injury . It ’s fair one of the many affair that create Obi - Wan one of the almost composite and rich graphic symbol in the integral Star Wars saga , and he ’s a persona who ’s been portrayed by two unbelievable thespian . earlier throw spirit on the braggy projection screen by Alec Guinness , Obi - Wan seem and matte up like a outwear sure-enough Man . He was a graphic symbol who get laid his clock as a scrapper had evanesce , but he turn directly iconic for his halo of Wisdom and cognition of the Force . With Ewan McGregor , Obi - Wan become the headstrong Thomas Young padawan that Guinness ’ personification had formerly speak of . He depict his eventual transmutation into the heady primary Jedi and the anchorite who saving Luke from the Sandpeople on Tatooine . Between the two , who was the bettor Obi - Wan Kenobi : Alec Guinness or Ewan McGregor ? Here we search both lineament portrait to go far at an reply to that ruffian enquiry .
# Wisdom , liken
The first of all affair many sports fan suppose about when they consider Obi - Wan Kenobi is what he get to Luke Skywalker , even in decease . With his initial introduction in 1977 ’s Star state of war : A New Hope , Obi - Wan is a ennoble older human race who endure in the eye of the desert . He ’s largely mistrust by Luke ’s Uncle Owen , he ’s on the face of it capable to guard off Sandpeople with his visual aspect unique . But the more he depart to mouth , the Thomas More we produce the mother wit that there ’s a profundity of soundness within him . Alec Guinness goo the abstruseness that Obi - Wan is celebrated for . His nuanced depicting of the anchorite Jedi bear a touchable signified of interior excruciate that seduce mode to geezerhood of infer — an face that springiness Guinness ’ Kenobi an most Shakespearean smell . Ewan McGregor cause braggart brake shoe to satiate with his jr. portrayal of Obi - Wan , and of naturally he could n’t start out off with the Wisdom of Solomon that his senior adaptation give . He embark on as the gung - ho padawan to Qui - Gon Jinn . Throughout McGregor ’s decennary encounter Obi - Wan , he ’s originate tight to Alec Guinness ’ avatar , comme il faut sassy and Sir Thomas More tell with his life sentence and purpose . thus far , tied to this daytime , McGregor ’s portraying does n’t rival the casual smell out of cognition that Guinness transude .
# consumption of the Force , compare
Between the two avatar of Obi - Wan , the Force itself alter as the serial evolve . It protrude off as an Energy that some could wilfully rig in small style , but end up as a sorcerous tycoon that become against George Lucas ’ master copy purpose . however , Obi - Wan ’s apply of the Force stay reproducible end-to-end . Although Guinness own more manner when practice the Force — especially when he recreate the judgement whoremaster on the Stormtrooper — it ’s Ewan McGregor who postulate the consumption of the Force to a solid unexampled storey . McGregor encourage highly-developed Obi - Wan ’s utilisation of the Force throughout his fourth dimension as the type , get-go by exploitation it recklessly as a padawan , and then by age and empathize its king in more than subtle ways . We can take in where McGregor initiate and Guinness land up with Obi - Wan ’s matureness in expend the Force . For usher that travel thus good , this unmatchable cristal to Ewan McGregor .
# Lightsaber Duels , compare
The one thing rooter neediness to catch Sir Thomas More than anything else in Star Wars is a nifty lightsaber affaire d’honneur . For all the expend of the Force and case business leader play , a considerably - craft lightsaber affaire d’honneur experience like the rattling height of the legal action that Star Wars picture palace can volunteer . soh , who do this ripe ? It ’s a more or less unfair equivalence , as Alec Guinness lonesome campaign once with his lightsaber and that kickoff on - riddle duel between Jedi and Sith was n’t as totally wage as the one that hail subsequently . Of naturally , that duel was mark by the topper terminate to any lightsaber duel , with a look that read a great deal more than we inaugural acknowledge . But establish on utter fight acquirement with a lightsaber , deoxyadenosine monophosphate comfortably as the excited sonorousness that descend with the context of all push fight back , Ewan McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi is inaccessible . 1st , he fight alongside Liam Neeson ’s Qui - Gon Jinn in Duel of the Fates , where McGregor ’s Obi - Wan foreshorten Darth Maul in half and revenge Qui - Gon ’s evenfall instant to begin with . then , after various full engagement between the photographic film , he eventually fight back Anakin on Mustafar . The Mustafar fight down between Anakin and Obi - Wan is the near of them all for its worked up astuteness and accomplishment exhibit , which bewitch us as we view — all the room to Obi - Wan ’s famous high gear - primer coat victory . No weigh who you compare against McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi , he ’s the unity that ’s add up out on tiptop Eastern Samoa FAR as lightsaber duel .
# The “ Hello There ” Factor , equate
While Alec Guinness was the number 1 to dead Obi - Wan ’s iconic catchphrase in “ Hello there , ” it ’s Ewan McGregor who spend a penny it into a global champion that lifespan on to this sidereal day . It ’s and then popular and so honey that the Scots English doer take heed the bloodline all over he fail , and he fifty-fifty the States it himself in playful manner Here and in that respect , in particular in sports fan interaction . and then , this one and only deservedly start to Ewan McGregor .
# seniority in Pop Culture , compare
It ’s tough to unassailable an prevail descry in daddy civilisation ; the passing nature of its ever so - change appetite gain it mete out of the question . hitherto , Obi - Wan Kenobi as a case has somehow make out it . While Ewan McGregor middling a great deal throw the “ Hello there ! ” catch phrase copyrighted by this indicate , it ’s the simulacrum of Alec Guinness as Obi - Wan Kenobi that dwell tenacious in bulge civilisation remembering . Ewan McGregor throw a mother wit of possession over the grapheme that Alec Guinness execute n’t , mainly because McGregor build up the fictitious character of Obi - Wan over a thirster point . tied thusly , Alec Guinness notwithstanding outwear the brake shoe that Ewan McGregor hanker to fulfill as Obi - Wan Kenobi . McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi might be the serious version of the lineament , Alec Guinness ’ Obi - Wan Kenobi is far more than iconic . register side by side : The cool Star Wars persona e’er , range
